Showing posts with label fines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fines. Show all posts
Tuesday, 13 May 2008
Unlicensed drivers
As from May 1st, the offence of driving without an appropriate licence has become imprisonable here in Spain. In the context that the average weekend sees around 20 deaths on Spain´s roads, half of them motorcyclists, something clearly needed to be done. The Traffic Division of the Guardia Civil set to with a will and so in the first few days of May a steady stream of (mainly young, male) offenders appeared before the court. So far I don´t believe a custodial sentence has been imposed, but hefty fines, coupled with community service are the order of the day. Thus an 18 year old was fined €2,000 and sentenced to 27 days of community working (about 160 hours by my reckoning). There was no pressure on the courts to constrain the fine within the offenders´ "ability to pay within a reasonable period".
Wednesday, 19 September 2007
Persistent Petty Offender
Several years ago we were involved in a pilot confronting the problem of the low level, low income offender with outstanding fines. These people were and still are the bane of a court's life. The offences they commit are not, in themselves, serious enough to merit more than a fine, but the offender is not able to pay any realistic fine imposed because (a) they have very little income and (b) they are already overloaded with outstanding fines fom previous offending.
The solution which we piloted, and which from the court's point of view was highly successful, was that in these circumstances we could find the person to be a 'persistent petty offender' and impose a community penalty instead. The type of pronouncement involved was: "We find that an appropriate fine for your offence would be (say) £250, but it is clear to us that you are not in a position to pay such a fine. We therefore sentence you to carry out 100 hours of community service over the next twelve months."
Most unusually, the end of the pilot was followed not by a national roll-out but by a period of review which for all I know is still going on. Suffice it to say, we lost this power. Could it be because the community penalty was more expensive to the system than an uncollectable fine? Or am I being cynical?
The solution which we piloted, and which from the court's point of view was highly successful, was that in these circumstances we could find the person to be a 'persistent petty offender' and impose a community penalty instead. The type of pronouncement involved was: "We find that an appropriate fine for your offence would be (say) £250, but it is clear to us that you are not in a position to pay such a fine. We therefore sentence you to carry out 100 hours of community service over the next twelve months."
Most unusually, the end of the pilot was followed not by a national roll-out but by a period of review which for all I know is still going on. Suffice it to say, we lost this power. Could it be because the community penalty was more expensive to the system than an uncollectable fine? Or am I being cynical?
Monday, 3 September 2007
Three of a kind (1)
I think the discovery that shocked me most when I first began to sit as a magistrate was the sheer number of people driving without insurance. Naively, I had always assumed that drivers insured their vehicles. I was wrong. Not only that, but the majority of uninsured drivers had no valid MOT and had never bothered to get a licence. The traffic court list usually contained about twenty such drivers per sitting. And most of them had previous convictions for the same offences.
Nothing has changed in that respect. Fourteen years later, I see the same numbers of the same offences whenever I sit in the traffic court. What has changed though is the fine we levy. In 1993 the standard fine for a first offence of no insurance was £540 set on the principle that it should be more expensive to be caught without insurance than it was to buy insurance. Somewhere along the line though a politically inspired change took place in the way we were instructed to calculate fines. It had to be related to the offender's financial means. Then the government decided that fixed penalties could be used for first offences of no insurance and the fixed penalty was set at £200. So we were instructed to impose the same figure if the case came to court (though we don't fine speeding cases that come to court this way). Result: Whereas the value of my house now stands at 410% of its 1993 value, a no insurance fine has fallen by 63% even without allowing for inflation. Little wonder that we are making no headway in deterring these offences.
I'll come to the matter of no licence in my next post.
Nothing has changed in that respect. Fourteen years later, I see the same numbers of the same offences whenever I sit in the traffic court. What has changed though is the fine we levy. In 1993 the standard fine for a first offence of no insurance was £540 set on the principle that it should be more expensive to be caught without insurance than it was to buy insurance. Somewhere along the line though a politically inspired change took place in the way we were instructed to calculate fines. It had to be related to the offender's financial means. Then the government decided that fixed penalties could be used for first offences of no insurance and the fixed penalty was set at £200. So we were instructed to impose the same figure if the case came to court (though we don't fine speeding cases that come to court this way). Result: Whereas the value of my house now stands at 410% of its 1993 value, a no insurance fine has fallen by 63% even without allowing for inflation. Little wonder that we are making no headway in deterring these offences.
I'll come to the matter of no licence in my next post.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)